In January 2011, the English-speaking world met a new kind of villain. She appeared in a viral Wall Street Journal article titled “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior.” The author, Amy Chua, a little-known Yale law professor, laid out her strict rules for her two daughters: no sleepovers, no playdates, no school plays—and no complaining about not being in the school play either. Her daughters were expected to be top students in every subject except gym and drama. When her seven-year-old refused to play a piano piece, Chua threatened to take away her lunch, dinner, and birthday parties for four years until she gave in. Another time, after the same daughter misbehaved, Chua called her “garbage.”
The backlash was immediate and harsh. Chua was called an abuser, a stereotype peddler, and a shock jock. The article was an excerpt from her memoir, Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, and Chua tried to explain that in the book, she reflects on the limits of her parenting style. But it was too late—the controversy had taken on a life of its own. Many Asian American writers responded by sharing their mixed feelings or anger about being raised that way. One blog post declared, “I grew up with a tiger parent and all I got was this lousy psychological trauma.” Suddenly, a common but private family dynamic was being debated publicly. There were endless letters, op-eds, blogs, tweets, and Facebook posts. Even my grandparents in China, who are as far removed from American media as possible, asked me about the American lady bragging about getting her kids into Harvard and giving Chinese people a bad name.
Reading Chua’s memoir recently, I was struck by its unapologetic and lighthearted tone, which feels like a product of its time. Today’s writers, more aware of the risks of going viral, are more cautious. But despite its unique notoriety, Chua’s book is part of a rich tradition of works from the East and Southeast Asian diaspora that explore complicated mother-daughter relationships. Two classic Chinese American novels—Maxine Hong Kingston’s The Woman Warrior and Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club—are built around real and imagined conversations between mothers and daughters. A key Chinese-British nonfiction work, Jung Chang’s Wild Swans, tells modern China’s turbulent history through the lives of Chang’s mother and grandmother. It was followed by the memoir Fly, Wild Swans, an intimate and painful love letter to the author’s own mother. In these works, the mother often becomes a deep, lasting wound—one that is constantly picked at and never fully heals.
This theme continues in film. The 2018 hit Crazy Rich Asians centers not on the main couple’s tension, but on the conflict between its Chinese American protagonist and her boyfriend’s distant Singaporean mother, played by Michelle Yeoh. Yeoh plays another difficult mother in the 2022 Oscar-winning film Everything Everywhere All at Once, this time as a stressed first-generation immigrant to the US who literally goes to the ends of the earth to reconnect with her queer daughter. That same year, Pixar released Turning Red, which follows a Chinese Canadian teenager trying to escape her overbearing mother.
These mothers don’t have the cartoonish villainy of Chua’s tiger mother. Yet they are often strict and hard to please, cold and prone to sudden outbursts of anger, mysterious and marked by sorrow. “For most of my childhood and adolescence, my mother was my antagonist,” recalls the narrator in Ling Ma’s highly praised novel Severance. British Chinese poet Sarah Howe’s collection Foretokens, inspired by her mother’s life in communist China, includes the very funny “A History of My Relationship With My Mother in 23 Arguments About the Laundry.” (One line reads: “I tried to show her that putting more than one towel in at once wouldn’t cause disaster, flood, or famine.”) Not long ago, I picked up Gish…Jen’s new memoir-novel, Bad Bad Girl, is inspired by her mother’s childhood in war-torn Shanghai. The title comes from the scolding Jen imagines her mother giving her from beyond the grave for writing so openly about private family issues. (A satirical cartoon about Asian American cinema sums up the genre’s themes in six words: “There’s this mom. And she’s bad.”)
Given how common this figure is, leaving out the mother can be a statement in itself. In Cathy Park Hong’s book Minor Feelings, she recalls a fellow poet once telling her, “You have an Asian mother. She has to be interesting.” Hong refuses to engage: “I must put it off, at least for now. I’d rather write about my friendship with Asian women first. My mother would take over, breaking through the walls of these essays, until it’s only her.”
Maybe she has a point. In these stories, the mother grows impossibly large; she becomes the way to explore questions of immigration, identity, and history. It’s in the conflict between mother and daughter that we see the cultural clashes between East and West. These stories are filled with the pain of not understanding each other—between the first-generation immigrant who has known hunger and hardship, and the second-generation child who craves love. The standoff seems impossible to resolve. In sentimental Hollywood movies, these characters end up having a healing reconciliation. In more serious works, the child tries to find some kind of resolution through their art, protected by the fact that the mother doesn’t understand English or has passed away.
Over drinks in London one evening last summer, I mentioned to some old school friends that I was thinking of writing about the persistent trope of the Asian mother. Polite small talk quickly ended, and we had two hours of passionate discussion. Afterward, I wanted to find a way into this subject, which I was now starting to see everywhere. The topic was too big to cover completely, so I started closer to home. Taking a very unscientific and scattered approach, I asked my friends if they could talk to me more about their relationships with their mothers.
It’s true that no matter which continent they’re from, mothers are an endless subject: the inevitable endpoint of a therapy session, the classic container of endless complaints, the shortcut to understanding a person’s quirks and insecurities. But there’s something about the Asian mother in popular culture that feels both overexposed and underdeveloped. What’s behind this constant return to the mother figure in literature, film, and our own lives? When we write about her flaws and failures, and our disappointments and broken inheritances, what exactly are we looking at? And what are we hoping to find?
A necessary disclaimer: not every Asian mother fits the stereotype, and not every Asian mother-daughter relationship is complicated and difficult. (We live in an age of hedging.) My friend Min says she’s identified three types of mother-child relationships. “The first, which I don’t understand, is people who are friends with their moms and tell them everything.” The second group are children “who have conflict with their parents, but it’s normal conflict.” And then, she says, “there’s this third group, where you have conflict, but it goes far beyond the conflict, and it’s very hard to explain to someone who’s never experienced it.” Min told me her mother “can make me feel worthless, useless, terrible, ungrateful; that she’s wasted her life on you, and you’re the worst person in the world, and you’ll never amount to anything.”
Min and I went to a competitive international school in Hong Kong, the kind that attracts status-conscious middle- and upper-class parents with high hopes for their children. To give you an idea: one of my fThings have changed so quickly in recent decades that you can feel the shock of being displaced without even moving countries. My friend Kai’s parents grew up poor in post-war Singapore and moved to mainland China when he was 10. “They saw themselves as having lived in the real world and suffered,” he said. They saw Kai, at least in his telling, as sheltered and naive. One day, Kai came home from his international school and told them he had learned about the importance of self-esteem. “My parents were like, ‘What Western bullshit concept is this? That’s for white kids. We don’t need that.’”
As adults, most of my friends have taken the easiest path: hiding what they can. In her memoir, Amy Chua compares tiger motherhood to being a military leader, mixing targeted action with constant secret scheming. She doesn’t mention that children quickly learn this game too. New partners are introduced as roommates. Appearances are kept up. None of this is surprising, given what’s at stake. Once, when a friend’s sister got a new boyfriend, their mom hired a private investigator to check him out. The boyfriend wasn’t shady. The mom just didn’t like him. In response, the sister moved out and refused to tell her mother her new address. I’m not immune to this deception and avoidance either. Only recently, at age 31, did I tell my mom about my college boyfriends.
If our mothers fit certain stereotypes, the same goes for my generation. My conversations with friends are full of therapy talk: revelations had, boundaries set, inherited trauma, the appeal of closure. We grew up on movies that end with cathartic tears and hugs, and promises never to hurt each other again. In real life, that’s not where most of my friends are with their mothers. Here are some things they say:
“Moving abroad has definitely improved our relationship. I can handle her in small doses. That’s pretty much it.”
“Our relationship is okay. It’s not quite satisfying, but it’s okay. I have much more respect and appreciation for everything she’s been through. And I try to keep that in mind as much as possible.”
“I’d say I have a good relationship with her. From my mom’s perspective, she thinks we’re closer than ever, she thinks we’re best friends. And that’s because I share much less now.”
“I went to therapy for the first time and gained a much richer vocabulary and understanding of my emotions and boundaries. And my mom, to her credit, was humble enough not to insist she was always right. She was open to learning from me. When I’d say, ‘Why do you say that? Why are you overreacting for no reason?’ she was willing to learn.”
“Basically, I’m managing something I don’t know how to handle. I feel sad for me, but also for her. I don’t have anyone who can be a parent figure because I can’t really rely on her for career or relationship advice. It’s really sad because, at the end of the day, her kids are the most important thing to her. But I’m avoiding her. My sibling is at best civil to her. We both think she’s been dealt a bad hand. But at the same time, we’re not invested.”
Hollywood endings can feel so far away in real life. No wonder mother-daughter relationships have been such rich material in art. Often, they’re a way to imagine the impossible. “Is that why I’m writing this, so I can remember my mother fondly?” Jen wonders out loud in Bad Bad Girl. “Is that the same as forgiving her?”
Then there’s the matter of love. Something that can get lost in these stories of grief, loss, and family conflict is that our mothers are capable of great courage and warmth. If they’re sometimes meddlesome and overbearing, they can also give us so much that it puts us to shame. (That’s the hard part, a friend said about her intense and oftenMy mother can be frustrating, but it’s only because she cares. She emigrated from China to New Zealand when I was born, hoping to give me a different life. In our home, just the two of us, we shared a closeness that could be intense and challenging at times. Other times, it was joyful—we’d laugh and plot together like sisters. She was—and still is—tough, strong-willed, and a dreamer. Her dreaming often showed up as a bright, unwavering belief in me. Unlike the stereotype of the ever-critical mother, she was convinced I was destined to be one of the greatest ballerinas, mathematicians, or whatever else the world had ever seen. (Imagine my shock as I grew up and realized I was bad at a lot of things.) She drilled into me the importance of being careful and responsible, so I was thrilled as a young child when I flipped through one of her old law textbooks—she worked at a law firm in China but had to get a new degree to practice in New Zealand—and found a note she’d scribbled in the margin: “BORING.”
That memory sticks with me because it was the first time I realized my mother was her own person, with her own private world and small acts of rebellion. For the most part, she seemed invincible, the way parents can seem to young kids. As I got older, I’d catch her in moments of exhaustion, feeling sad about being so far from everything she knew. We moved to Hong Kong when I was 12 to be closer to family, and from then on, I started to sense there was a whole other side to my mother’s life that I couldn’t reach.
When I asked my mum if I could interview her about her life, she said yes right away. We talked over several video calls—me in London, her in New Zealand—and she spoke freely, often with heartbreaking honesty. Some of the stories she shared were familiar, bits of anecdotes I’d heard years ago, but now they had more context. And when I asked her about her own experience of being a mother, she told me things I’d never heard before.
She grew up as the oldest of four kids in a big family near Wuhan. As the eldest daughter, she was always reminded she had to act like a mother to her younger brother, the prized son. But the thing that really shaped her childhood was the Cultural Revolution. Her mother was a schoolteacher and her father a writer—”intellectual” jobs that marked them as “bad elements.” When she was three, she watched her father, my grandfather, get dragged out to be publicly shamed by a crowd during what were called “struggle sessions,” with Red Guards holding his arms down. The family was criticized on big posters all over the neighborhood. Classmates threw rocks at her. Loudspeakers set up outside her home blasted criticisms of the family.
“I grew up in a very depressing environment,” my mum said. Moving to New Zealand wasn’t easy for her. She took odd jobs, relied on other Chinese immigrants for childcare, and often felt overwhelmed being alone in a new country. But she stayed. “I wanted you to have a happy childhood,” she told me. “I didn’t want my bad feelings to spill over into your life.”
Of course, “bad feelings” have a way of finding their way to the next generation. When my mum shared her story with me, I had this strange feeling that I was putting together pieces of a puzzle that had been lurking in my subconscious since I was very young—things I’d picked up from conversations I probably wasn’t meant to overhear. But unlike when I was a child, when I couldn’t fully believe the past was real or that my mother was once a child herself, hearing this now made me feel a deep sadness for everything she’d been through.
We often talk about “digesting” or “working through” emotions, as if they’re things to be sent down a factory line in our bodies to be broken down and processed.Packaged anew. But my mother’s childhood feels so vast and hard to grasp that it’s difficult to take in. Yet for the same reason, I can’t let it go.
When we talked, I told her I struggle with the gap between my life and the one she had. I said I feel the weight of the sacrifices she made for me, and I spend much of my life trying to be worthy of them. That wasn’t how she saw it. While I focused on the hardships she faced as a young mother, she remembered it as an energizing experience—she finally learned to drive, for one—that pushed her to be her best. “To be clear,” she said, “I don’t think I’ve made any sacrifice for you. I never thought I did something called sacrifice. I never saw it that way. I think you deserve everything I’ve done for you. I wish I could have done more.”
In conversations with friends, one line always comes up. It goes something like: “If I have kids, I want to do things differently. I’ll break the cycle.” Then it’s usually followed by: “But I worry that without that pressure, I’ll raise ungrateful, lazy children.” And it ends with some horrified observation about the liberties some of their white friends take with their parents.
My friends and I are now in our early 30s. Babies are everywhere, and with babies come good intentions that will go wrong. For all the ways my friends have been let down by their mothers, it’s striking how many of those mothers also tried to do things differently. And yet here we are, with all our bad feelings. In the most intimate and intense way, maybe a mother’s fate is just the fate of all humanity: to have your best intentions go unnoticed and your best efforts fall short. We will love and disappoint our own children. A new generation will come after us, and new novels, films, and poems will emerge in our wake. They will discover new stories and themes—and inevitably, some of them will examine our love and our failures.
Names have been changed.
Discover a selection of the Guardian’s finest longform writing in one beautifully illustrated magazine. In this issue, you’ll find stories about how private equity is plundering the world and what it’s like growing up in a family of Nazis. Plus: why do we think the perfect stroller will make us better parents? Order your copy here (delivery charges may apply). Listen to our podcasts here and sign up for the long read weekly email here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here is a list of FAQs about the complex topic of the Asian mother stereotype written in a natural tone with clear concise answers
BeginnerLevel Questions
1 What is the Asian mother stereotype
Its the common idea that Asian mothers are strict demanding laserfocused on academic success and emotionally reserved Think Tiger Mom
2 Why does this stereotype make people feel bad
It creates pressure to live up to an impossible standard If you dont get perfect grades or a highpaying job you might feel like a failure It also overshadows the love and care many Asian mothers actually show
3 Is the Asian mother stereotype true
No its a huge oversimplification While some Asian mothers might fit parts of it it ignores the huge diversity in parenting styles personalities and cultures across Asia Its a caricature not a reality
4 Where does this stereotype come from
It comes from a mix of things Western media portrayals cultural differences in parenting being misunderstood and a long history of seeing Asian people as a model minority who are naturally hardworking
5 How is this stereotype different from just having strict parents
The key is the cultural weight The stereotype ties strictness directly to being Asian It implies a whole ethnic group shares the same rigid emotionally cold parenting style which isnt fair or accurate
Intermediate Advanced Questions
6 What are the bad feelings the title is talking about
Things like shame guilt anxiety and a constant sense of not being good enough Its the feeling that your mothers love is conditional on your achievements and the pressure to sacrifice your own happiness for family expectations
7 Why does this stereotype dominate everything
It becomes the lens through which people see all Asian mothers and their children A sons low grade isnt just a bad test its seen as a failure of the Asian mother system A daughters career choice isnt just a job its a rebellion against the stereotype It colors every interaction
8 How does this stereotype hurt Asian mothers themselves
It boxes them in They might feel pressured to be the Tiger Mom even if its not their
