Alkali ya yanke hukuncin cewa Duke na Sussex da wasu masu shigar da kara guda shida da aka fi sani dole ne su biya fam miliyan 9.54 da karfe 4 na yamma a ranar 28 ga Agusta a matsayin biyan kuɗi na wucin gadi zuwa ga kuɗaɗen shari'a na mawallafin Daily Mail. Wannan ya biyo bayan rashin nasarar da suka yi a wata shari'a a babbar kotu game da zarge-zargen tattara bayanai ba bisa ka'ida ba. Associated Newspapers Ltd (ANL) ta musanta karara zarge-zargen da Yarima Harry da sauran masu shigar da kara suka yi, ciki har da Doreen Lawrence da Elton John.
Mista Alkali Nicklin ya yi watsi da dukkan zarge-zargen a watan da ya gabata bayan shari'ar da ta kwashe makonni 11 a Landan a farkon wannan shekara. An gaya wa kotu cewa jimillar kuɗaɗen ANL sun haura fam miliyan 34. Lauyoyin masu shigar da kara, waɗanda suka haɗa da David Furnish, Sadie Frost, Liz Hurley, da Sir Simon Hughes, sun yi jayayya cewa biyan kuɗin na wucin gadi ya kamata ya zama sama da fam miliyan 7.9 kawai.
Alkalin ya kuma yanke shawarar cewa ya kamata a tantance kuɗaɗen ANL bisa tsarin diyya (indemnity basis), wanda ya fi dacewa ga mawallafin dangane da yawan abin da zai iya dawo da shi, sai dai inda an riga an yi umarni. Wannan yana nufin cewa, a matsayin ƙungiyar da ta yi rashin nasara, yariman da sauran dole ne su biya kuɗaɗen ANL ba tare da buƙatar mawallafin ya tabbatar da cewa waɗannan kuɗaɗen sun dace kuma sun yi daidai ba. Tsarin diyya ba shi da yawa fiye da tsarin daidaitaccen tsari kuma yana buƙatar ɗabi'a ko yanayi waɗanda suke "a waje da al'ada."
A wani zaman da aka yi a watan Yuli, an gaya wa kotu cewa Associated ta kashe kuɗaɗen shari'a na fam miliyan 34.5.
Nicklin ya ce ba "shari'a ce kawai da aka yi zarge-zarge masu tsanani kuma aka kasa tabbatar da su ba," ko kuma "yaƙin shari'a ne kawai da aka yi wahala, inda bayan dogon shari'a, kotu ta fifita shaidu da maganganun wani bangare a kan ɗayan." Ya kara da cewa: "Zarge-zargen, da yadda aka kawo su, aka rubuta su, aka bi su, aka kiyaye su, da kuma gabatar da su a bainar jama'a, sun haɗa da haɗin yanayi da ɗabi'a waɗanda suka fitar da shari'ar daga yadda ake gudanar da shari'ar farar hula ta al'ada kuma mai ma'ana."
A cikin hukuncinsa mai shafuffuka 44, ya ba da kuɗaɗen bisa wannan tsari mai tsauri saboda dalilai da yawa, ciki har da "yanayin hasashe da rashin tushe na zarge-zargen a farkonsu," "faɗin da ba a saba gani ba" na shari'o'in, "da kuma gabatar da zarge-zargen manyan laifuka da rashin da'a a bainar jama'a waɗanda ba a tabbatar da su ba a ƙarshe." Ya kuma soki ƙungiyar saboda "yin da kuma kiyaye zarge-zarge masu tsanani game da mutane da yawa, rashin sake tantance waɗannan zarge-zargen lokacin da shaidu suka buƙaci sake tantancewa, da kuma ci gaba da bin zarge-zargen da ba su da goyon baya ko kuma waɗanda ba za a iya ci gaba da su ba a zahiri." Ya kammala: "A ganina, wannan ɗabi'a ba ta da ma'ana sosai."
Alkalin ya ƙi iyakance kuɗaɗen.
A cikin wata sanarwa, ANL ta ce hukuncin "sukar da ke lalata ƙoƙarin halaka jarida da sunayen 'yan jarida, editoci, da shugabanninta." Ta kara da cewa duk da "rushewar shaidu don tallafawa zarge-zargen da suka fi tsanani na 'mummunan ayyukan laifi, laifuka, da munanan ayyukan ɓoye da ba a yarda da su ba' na Mail," zarge-zargen "ba a janye su ba, kuma an bi su har zuwa ƙarshen shari'ar." Sanarwar ta ci gaba: "Gaskiyar ita ce, waɗannan zarge-zargen na rashin kunya bai kamata a kawo su ba. Cewa an bi su yana tayar da tambayoyi masu tayar da hankali game da ɗabi'ar wasu sassan ƙungiyar lauyoyi."
Hughes ya ce ya "yi takaici da mamaki" cewa alkali ya ƙi iyakance kuɗaɗen.
Hukuncin ba ya nufin ANL na da damar dawo da duk kuɗaɗen da ta kashe ba. Duk wani kuɗi da aka kashe ba bisa ka'ida ba za a ƙi shi. Idan ɓangarorin ba su iya yarda ba, alkali mai tantance kuɗaɗen zai tantance kuɗaɗen. Ƙungiyoyin suna da har zuwa 2 ga Oktoba don neman izinin ɗaukaka ƙara kan hukuncin shari'ar ko hukuncin kuɗaɗen.
Tambayoyin da Aka Yi Yawaita
Anan akwai jerin tambayoyin da aka yi yawaita game da Yarima Harry da biyan kuɗin fam miliyan 9.5 na wucin gadi ga mawallafin Daily Mail wanda aka rubuta cikin salo na halitta kuma mai sauƙin fahimta
Tambayoyin Gabaɗaya na Asali
1 Menene wannan biyan kuɗin fam miliyan 9.5
Biyan kuɗi ne na wucin gadi zuwa ga kuɗaɗen shari'a Yarima Harry da sauran masu shigar da kara an umarce su da su biya wannan kuɗin ga Associated Newspapers Limited mawallafin Daily Mail don rufe kuɗaɗen shari'a da aka kashe har yanzu a cikin shari'ar Ba tarar ba ne ko kuma sulhu ba
2 Me yasa suke biyan kuɗaɗen ɗayan bangaren
A cikin kotunan farar hula na Burtaniya ƙa'idar gabaɗaya ita ce wanda ya yi rashin nasara zai biya kuɗaɗen shari'a na wanda ya ci nasara Alkali ya yanke hukuncin cewa babban zargi na mashahuran—cewa ANL ta ɗauki hayar masu bincike masu zaman kansu don yin satar waya da motoci ba bisa ka'ida ba—yana da rauni sosai kuma yana da ƙarancin damar samun nasara Saboda sun kawo shari'a marar ƙarfi, alkali ya umarce su da su biya kuɗaɗen ANL don kare kanta daga wannan ɓangaren na musamman na zargin
3 Shin wannan ƙarshen shari'ar ne
A'a Wannan zagaye na farko ne kawai Shari'ar tana ci gaba har yanzu amma an rage ta sosai Alkali ya watsar da wasu ɓangarorin zargin amma ƙaramin ɓangare—wanda ya shafi takamaiman zarge-zargen tattara bayanai ba bisa ka'ida ba—zai ci gaba zuwa shari'a
4 Menene ainihin abin da alkali ya ce game da shari'ar
Alkali Mista Justice Nicklin ya soki shaidun masu shigar da kara sosai Ya ce shari'arsu ta dogara ne akan hasashe da zato kawai kuma ba ta dace da shari'a ba a yanayin da take a yanzu Ya musamman ya ce zargin satar waya yana da ƙarancin damar samun nasara
Kuɗaɗen da Hukuncin
5 Nawa ne jimillar kuɗaɗen shari'a zai kasance
Fam miliyan 9.5 biyan kuɗi ne na wucin gadi kawai Jimillar kuɗaɗen shari'a na ƙarshe na ɓangarorin biyu na iya zama mafi girma sosai, mai yiwuwa ya kai dubun-dubatan miliyoyin fam, dangane da yadda sauran shari'ar za ta kasance
6 Wanene ke biyan kuɗaɗen shari'a na Yarima Harry
Ba a bayyana wannan a bainar jama'a ba A baya ya yi amfani da kuɗi daga wata amana da mahaifiyarsa Gimbiya Diana ta kafa Shi ma yana da
